Medical Insurance, American-Style: Part Two--The HMO v. The PPO


 The Scream by Edvard Munch 1893 - Courtesy Wikipedia

Dear Friends,

I hope that everyone is well.  This week has been eventful, to say the least.  

But I digress...

To continue our discussion of American medical insurance and why I cannot simply go either here or here to have the surgery, we must address the difference between an HMO and a PPO medical insurance plan.

The Preferred Provider Organization (PPO)

The PPO is the way to go, IF one can afford the premium.  

The PPO gives people the maximum number of choices.  As a generality, Preferred Providers exist from coast-to-coast and the patient decides which provider to access.  In addition, to become a member of the PPO, a physician or other provider must hold higher credentials than those who serve HMO patients.

My primary physician, who graduated from a Caribbean medical school, lacks the credentials to be part of any of the local PPOs.

Had I the PPO-type medical insurance, I could have had the surgery that I need within a month.  I would have called the Norman Center, had a consultation, and scheduled the surgery. 

However, in my locale for a woman of my age, a PPO plan would run me over half my monthly income, have a deductible of $2500 and an out-of-pocket maximum of $6850 a year, and include actually very reasonable co-payments.

The Health Maintenance Organization (HMO)

The HMO, in my opinion, should really be called the "Health Gatekeeper Organization" because another person--the primary physician--decides what care one will and will not receive.

Many HMOs hire any physician who will work for the company's relatively low rate of pay.  

I have had excellent care by two of my HMO's physician. 

One--Dr. Nicholas A. Raubitschek, MD--was educated at a medical school in Israel, spoke and understood English, listened, and behaved respectfully.  I was blessed to have him as my primary physician for six months.  Nicholas is the grandson of one of my favorite scholars, Isabelle Raubitschek, whose work completely changed my perspective on Ancient Greece.

The second--Dr. Bryan Klassen, MD, PhD--caught two serious prescription mistakes that my primary allegedly might have made and corrected those alleged mistakes.  Enough said.

My primary physician graduated from a medical school in the Caribbean and, frankly, in my opinion, is not the brightest bulb in the pack.  He is the best one available to me.  English is his first language, he sometimes listens to me, and he showers and grooms himself on a regular basis.  

An HMO in my area for a woman of my age runs about a third of my monthly income, but that's it.  As long as I remain within the HMO network of providers (which is quite small), the premium is it after the deductible is met.  If emergency care is needed outside the area, the care is covered as if I received it at the local hospital.

The real trouble comes when the patient requires care beyond the scope of the HMO.  

In the case of a large HMO, such as Kaiser, that rarely happens because some branch of the HMO will offer nearly any needed service.  

In the case of a small HMO, a patient will end up jumping through hoops at a teaching hospital, such as I have been doing with Stanford Medical Center for two months.  

Since three parathyroid adenomas have been found, I am guessing that Stanford will deem me qualified for surgery.  

If not, I am back to Dr. X to beg him for another referral.

Or pay cash on the barrelhead for surgery in Florida.

Sending you my love,
Cynthia 💗


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Surprise! Surprise! Surprise!

Arizona, Here I Come!

I Am Astounded...